Arthur of the Ancient and Illuminated Seers of Bavaria (who says it’s okay to blog this) writes:
Amongst other things, I enjoy reading murder mysteries, especially those from the golden age of the English whodunnit in the 20s and 30. Recently I’ve been reading up on the lives of some of those authors and I came across something rather surprising.
Of the five great authors of the English golden age, Agatha Christie, Margery Allingham, Dorothy L. Sayers, G.K. Chesterton and Ronald Knox, all but one (Christie) were Catholic! Indeed of those three (Sayers, Chesterton and Knox) were also serious authors on philosophical matters and theology. Okay Knox was primarily a theologian who dabbled in mystery writing, but you get my drift. 🙂
I’m not sure exactly what that means, but I found it interesting.
I’m not sure what it means, either. It could be random chance, but . . .
. . . Jack Chick might take it as evidence that Catholics just have murderous tendencies.
. . . Some psychologists might take it as evidence that British Catholics have murderous thoughts, given how much they suffered persecution from the British Crown and how much alienation they suffered in British society.
. . . I might take it to mean that there’s an intellectual streak in Catholicism that results in its authors liking intellectual puzzles and this tendency then manifesting in literary form (the murder mystery being a familiar form of intellectual puzzle in fiction).
What’s your explanation for the phenomenon?