A reader writes:
I hope you will answer my question concerning the uses of Holy Water. I to like have and use holy water at home. So when I travel I like to pick up holy water from different churches. Its a nice way to visit other churches, the priest, parisherners and to collect holy water.
Recently I was in my home town. There is more than one chuch in this particular city. I went to one particular church there and I was
very much disappointed in the way I was treated because I wanted holy water. Never in all the years I have been catholic, and I am cradle born have I been so disppointed by the way I was treated by the church secretary and even the deacon himself because I wanted holy water. I was told that they had found that people were using holy water for sacriliege purposes. Upon hearing that I didn’t know whether to cry or laugh. I could understand a secretary being ignorant to the use of Holy Water but I can’t understand the ignorance of a church deacon. They even had the nerve to ask me if that was my intended purpose.
My question is, Can holy water be use sacrilegiously? My mind, heart and soul says "No Way!"
Well eventually I did get my holy water but not after I had recieved the third degree. I finally had to ask, Are you going to deny me taking holy water from this church? I had to ask three times. Each time they said no but they were not too happy because I wanted holy water. I don’t understand. I was really confounded by their behavior.
You certain encountered a very unusual circumstance and it’s understandable that you’d feel confused and disappointed.
It is at least possible for a person to use holy water–or any sacramental–for a sacreligious purpose. For example, an evil cult might take some and (God forbid) use it mockingly in ceremonies worshipping the devil or something.
Hypothetically, the local parish may hae turned up such a group–or perhaps just a couple of rebellious teenagers–using it for a genuinely sacreligious purpose.
I also wonder if there might have been a communications problem here. It also is possible for people to use holy water superstitiously–as if God were definitely going to use it to accomplish certain miracles or as if it had magical powers or needed to be used in all kinds of circumstances where it doesn’t. It is much easier for me to imagine people using holy water supertitiously than sacreligiously.
If the parish staff–including the deacon–were not used to having folks show up and ask for holy water and someone showed up and asked for a significant quantity, they may have wondred–out of a misplaced and possibly puritanical sense of zeal–wondered whether it would be used superstitiously, even if not sacreligiously. The deacon might have then misspoke and said "sacreligious" when he meant "superstitious."
I don’t know that this is the explanation. It’s just conjecture. But it’s something that might lead to the kind of unfortunate experience you had.