Bouncy Concrete

Mission_valley Lemme tell you a story: Here in San Diego there is a place called Mission Valley, which is where Mission San Diego ("California’s First Church") is located. (It–the church, not Mission Valley–was built over 200 years ago, before the founding in the U.S.)

I used to live right next to Mission San Diego and thus in Mission Valley.

Down the midst of Mission Vallue is the I-8 interstate.

Bisecting Mission Valley along its north-south axis is the 805 freeway.

The 805 doesn’t cross the bottom of Mission Valley, though. Instead, flung across the valley is a huge bridge, (what seems like) hundreds of feet in the air.

I get a little nervous whenever I have to cross the Mission Valley Bridge. (I once saw a too-quickly-lane-changing pickup there flip over right in front of me, killing the man and pregnant woman inside it.)

But it’s a major traffic exchange point in San Diego (photographed above by satellite), and when I lived in Mission Valley, I regularly used it.

Particularly because had friends who lived on the north side of Mission Valley, right near where the 805 bridge rejoins solid ground.

It was really convenient to go over to their house! I’d just get on the I-8, head towards the Mission Valley Bridge, and then zoom up ramp to the 805 and the point where their house was.

On the way home afterwards, I’d head down the Mission Valley Bridge, take the exit ramp curving down to the I-8, and in a few minutes I’d be home.

Now: One Friday night I was heading down the 805/Mission Valley Bridge ramp and my car (didn’t have a pickup at the time) suffered a DOUBLE BLOW-OUT. Both of my rear tires popped.

Quickly, I worked my way into the emergency lane and stopped the car. I got out to see if I could change the tires and discovered this was impossible. Not only did I not have two spares, the car consumed the entire width of the emergency lane on the bridge, meaning that my body would have to hang out into Friday night traffic if I even attempted to change the tires.

Not a good solution.

I therefore started trudging back up the incline until I reached an emergency callbox, where I could call for help. (This was in the ’90s, before I had a cell phone.)

After trudging up half a mile or so (that’s how big the bridge is), I finally reached the callbox and summoned a tow-truck. I then returned to my car to wait.

At this point in my life, I was (foolishly) suppressing the Southern elements in my speech, except that they would come out when I was either very relaxed or under stress. Needless to say, I was twangin’ up a storm by the time the tow-truck guy arrived.

Once he got there, I waited in the cab of the truck and he used it’s mechanism to slide a big metal plate under my car, which the truck then lifted up and redeposited it onto the back of the truck.

As it picked my car up off the roadway and redeposited it, the truck vibrated MIGHTILY, ROCKING BACK AND FORTH IN THE EMERGENCY LANE PRECIPITOUSLY, WITH ME IN THE CAB LOOKING DOWN INTO (WHAT SEEMED LIKE) HUNDREDS OF FEET OF DARKNESS OVER THE CONCRETE RAILING AND SAYING PRAYERS TO WHOEVER THE PATRON SAINT OF BRIDGE-BUILDING MIGHT BE (St. Patrick, among others, as I later determined).

The tow-truck guy towed me home in mere minutes, and all was well that ended well. (I bought new tires the next day.)

Now: What brings this story to mind?

When I was walking up the incline to get to the emergency phone, I noticed something very disturbing: The Mission Valley Bridge . . . BOUNCED.

As cars would zoom past me toward whatever Friday night merriments they had planned, the roadway under my feet . . . BOUNCED. It wasn’t rigid. It was made out of concrete, of course, but still it . . . BOUNCED.

In earthquake-prone California, bouncy bridges are important.

The reason is that structures that have a little "give" in them have less of a tendency to break. That’s why the wings of an airplane are designed to bounce when they encounter turbulence. If they were rigid, they’d snap off. I therefore know I’m safer if I’m sitting over the wings and see them bouncing–thought I still don’t like it. It annoys my pre-reflective sensibility that rigid structures are stronger than flexible structures.

Flexible_concrete Tonight I was thinking about this because I ran across

A STORY ABOUT EXTRA-FLEXIBLE CONCRETE.

It may not have the zing of transluent concrete, but it’s zingy (and bouncy) enough.

EXCERPTS:

By mixing fiber in concrete scientists have created a bendable material that is lightweight, resists cracking, and lasts longer.

Fiber-reinforced concrete is not new. But this variety, developed at the University of Michigan, is said to be 500 times more resistant to cracking than what your sidewalk is made of. It’s also 40 percent lighter.

The stuff is called Engineered Cement Composites (ECC).

The Michigan Department of Transportation (MDOT) will use the ECC to replace part of a bridge that crosses Interstate 94. The slab will eliminate the need for expansion joints, which are moveable steel teeth that separate sections of regular concrete. With the ECC, a longer continuous slab will be possible.

The Mihara Bridge, a new structure in Hokkaido, Japan, has a deck of ECC that is a mere 2 inches (5 centimeters) thick. It is expected to open this month.

God bless the folks who have blow-outs on the Mihara Bridge!

Author: Jimmy Akin

Jimmy was born in Texas, grew up nominally Protestant, but at age 20 experienced a profound conversion to Christ. Planning on becoming a Protestant seminary professor, he started an intensive study of the Bible. But the more he immersed himself in Scripture the more he found to support the Catholic faith, and in 1992 he entered the Catholic Church. His conversion story, "A Triumph and a Tragedy," is published in Surprised by Truth. Besides being an author, Jimmy is the Senior Apologist at Catholic Answers, a contributing editor to Catholic Answers Magazine, and a weekly guest on "Catholic Answers Live."

17 thoughts on “Bouncy Concrete”

  1. Last week I drove on the motorway for the very first time,(due to an emergency situation) and I prayed the whole 2 hours and 45 minutes that it took to get to my destination. I would probably have a cardiac arrest if I had to drive over a bouncy bridge.
    God Bless

  2. If I had a double blowout I would probably need the motor club to bring me some clean underwear.
    What are the odds?

  3. Have you watched the footage of Tacoma Narrows? It’s mind-boggling how much it could flex.

  4. Have you watched the footage of Tacoma Narrows? It’s mind-boggling how much it could flex.
    Watching it bounce was weird enough. Watching it twist in the wind like a ribbon was downright frightening. Thank goodness no one was killed.

  5. Now that you have mentioned this I am going to take a drive down to Mission Valley via the 805.
    I wish I had seen this blog earlier, if it was up in the morning that is, because I happened to be down in that very area shopping in Fashion Valley.
    gah!

  6. This reminds me of when I was in a 60 story building in Tulsa, OK. In the upper floors on a windy day you could actally feel the building slo-o-o-wly move.
    Creepy!

  7. Living in San Diego county, I really like these posts with a local flavor. The construction at the I-805 and 5 merge is using some neat technology to prevent earthquake damage. Things like underground rock pillars to prevent liquefaction and geo grid blankets on slopes to prevent land slides.

  8. Oh crud. You have just ruined my anticipation of my upcoming vacation. I am heading to San Diego (my sister lives in Rancho Santa Fe) in July, and now I’ll be a wreck thinking about that bridge. I have bridge phobia — cannot ever drive over one if it is curved, arched, over water, or over a gorge. I have terrible panic attacks. I can be a passenger IF I close my eyes and ears! Great. And I do believe that new bridge on I-94 is being built at this very moment, and is on my commute to work. Yikes.
    ‘thann

  9. Don’t worry! If you’re going to Rancho Santa Fe, that’s *way* north of Mission Valley. You won’t have to cross the bridge or at least would be able to avoid it. 🙂

  10. As I recall I heard that the Tacoma narrows got out of control because of the sound that the wind made when blowing through the wires holding the bridge. The sound reached resonance with the concrete of the bridge and … well you saw the results.
    I’m not sure if I’m remembering correctly. I suppose I could google to see if that’s true.
    Brian

  11. Maybe now that they such special concrete, the folks in Michigan will actually get around to paving Detroit. Those streets look like they’ve taken mortar shells.

  12. Yup, bridges bounce. Whenever bands or military units or anybody, really, is marching in a parade, they are supposed to break step when crossing a bridge. If they don’t, the bridge will start bouncing and swaying at it resonant frequency. I remember one time back in High School we were marching across the Panther Hollow Bridge in Oakland (the Oakland near Pittsburgh, where Pitt and Carnegie-Mellon are). We didn’t break step and folks started stumbling and several thought they were getting dizzy when it was actually the bridge bouncing from our marching.

  13. As Sean above was pointing out, all bridges bounces. We often don’t notice when driving in our cars.
    If you want have fun with bridges, I suggest the Royal Gorge suspension bridge in Canon City Colorado. As you walk across the bridge, you can certianly feel it sway and bounce. You can see 1098 feet down through the slats which also move individually when cars slowly drive by.
    The tradition is to take a picture next to your home state flag which hanges on along both side of the bridge. Texas is probably close to the middle. 🙂
    More info: Royal Gorge Bridge

  14. Phantom Planet MP3 Downloads – Phantom Planet Music Downloads

    All Full Albums, World Charts, Top 20’s, 40’s, 50’s, 100’s, mp3 links…

Comments are closed.