In the media’s perennial case of Not Getting It, pundits are speculating that Benedict XVI’s papacy is tilting more to the left than to the right, something not expected from someone they presumed to be the spiritual incarnation of Torquemada.
"[Pope Benedict XVI’s] crowds are far larger than those of Pope John Paul II at the same time last year. Sunday addresses from his apartment window have drawn up to 100,000 people. And so far, to the surprise of many, the new pope’s words and deeds have drawn sharper criticism from the Catholic far right than from the left.
"John Allen, Vatican analyst of the liberal National Catholic Reporter, analyzed nearly 45,000 words that Benedict spoke in his first 45 days. They proved mostly positive, not the attacks on secularism and heresy many expected from Ratzinger, Allen said.
"’There is an obvious sense of alarm from the right that this pontificate will not deliver the strong conservative agenda that that wing of the church was expecting,’ said Allen, who just completed his second biography of Ratzinger/Benedict."
GET THE STORY.
While it is true that so far I have seen far sharper attacks on Pope Benedict since his election coming from Rad Trads than from Rad Progs®, this is once more a case of pitting pastoral care against doctrinal clarity.
What many on both sides seem to be missing is that Joseph Ratzinger has a different job now as Pope Benedict than he had as Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger. It’s not that he can be expected to neglect doctrinal clarity; only that he will approach it in a different manner as pope than he did as prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. And, in addition, he has far greater opportunity and visibility as pope to show pastoral sensitivity than he did as head of the CDF.
The truly Rad Trad Catholics, with a few exceptions, never expected much from Pope Benedict XVI because they more or less dismissed him as a "Novus Ordo Pope." The Rad Progs have not expected much from him either, and are a bit surprised that he has not yet put anyone in a Jedi death grip. (Even in the case of Fr. Thomas Reese, S.J., former editor of America, the article notes that his story is mainly considered to be the last act of Cardinal Ratzinger rather than the first of Pope Benedict.)
Those truly in danger of disappointment are those orthodox Catholics who expected Pope Benedict to be SuperPope. And, not only SuperPope, but a SuperPope made in their own image and likeness of what they believe a SuperPope should be and do.